In a conversation over dinner yesterday, I got on the topic of computer forensics and the proper methods for inspecting a system for evidence or, as was the case yesterday, objectionable material.
The issue was that of a computer, owned by a minor, on which were found pictures of said minor engaging in activities of a sexual nature.
Now, in this particular case, the problem was handled by the family and there were no outside parties (e.g. authorities) involved.
However, consider the case of a simple troubleshooting or tech-support house call. If I or another consultant were to perform maintenance on a user's home system and discover material that could land the owner in serious legal hot water...what's the best course of action to take? As a professional, as a member of society, as someone who, quite frankly,
wants nothing to do with it.
Consider also the case of deleting files on a client's system to improve performance. If cache files contained images or other binary files that could be used as evidence in a child-pornography investigation, and a consultant were to delete them as part of a system cleanup (unwittingly, of course), does that make him an accessory to the crime? Is he aiding and abetting a sex offender by removing evidence, even if he only aimed to clear out unnecessary data? How does intent play into a scenario such as this?
Also, what if he offered backup services in the form of binary system images (think PQDI or Ghost), and a customer's system contained information that was considered illegal or "suspect," such as a PDF copy of the Anarchist's Cookbook. He'd have those files, albeit not individually accessible, on backup media in his possession as a means of data protection for his client. Does this mean he's now in possession of child porn or terrorist handbooks?
Questions, comments, and other feedback are welcome. The law is a bizarre and tricky beast, to be sure.